If a disciple discovers that his “guru” was never qualified as such, that he was cheated in accepting a common sinful person as spiritual guide, then he should immediately reject him.
But it can’t be called “Guru rejection” because that person was never a Guru.
Then he has to take initiation, but should not call it reinitiation because the previous “initiation” was fake.
If a disciple realizes that his Guru is not very advanced or not a liberated soul, but follows Vaisnava lifestyle, then he can’t be rejected. Doing that is a most serious offense.
You find below several of Srila Prabhupada’s statements on this topic. Also I have included some statements from Narahari Sarakara Thakura, a contemporary of Lord Caitanya Mahaprabhu.
It has to be noted that giving initiation to an already initiated devotee is an offense also on the part of the new Guru, because giving reinitiation is an act of despice. It’s like saying, “he is not even a Vaisnava”.
Diksa is one for life.
There is no such a thing as “reinitiation”.
Different is the case if the devotee accepts a siksa guru to receive more advanced instructions. That is quite normal and acceptable in our tradition. But a devotee should do that after taking the blessings of the Diksa Guru.
“If one’s initiating spiritual master and instructing spiritual master are of small spiritual potency, or in other words, if they do not possess a special power to give spiritual instruction on worship for devotional service, then one may listen from the mouth of other great advanced Vaisnavas and understand the special instructions. However, thereafter, the disciple must go to his spiritual master for his confirmation or instructions.”
(Krishna Bhajanamrita Verse 46)
If the son earns money but does not give it to the father and instead, directly enjoys the wealth, he is considered to be a fallen son and a sinful person. Similarly, a disciple who listens to the words of other Vaisnavas, even if their instructions are proper and true, but does not reconfirm these teachings with his own spiritual master and instead directly personally accepts these instructions, is considered a bad disciple and a sinner.
(Krishna Bhajanamrita Verse 49)
Srila Prabhupada said
But it doesn’t matter that degree. Actually, if the Guru teaches Krishna consciousness, then he may be in lesser degree, but he is accepted as Guru. There is no question of rejection.
(Lecture, Ahmedabad 13/12/72)
If one has accepted a bona fide spiritual master and he did not receive much knowledge from him, can he change his spiritual master at later…
A bona fide spiritual master, where is the necessity of changing?
No, he has not got the knowledge from him, but… can I change..?
No, no, bona fide spiritual means he must get knowledge. He must get knowledge. He must inquire from the… The student must inquire from the spiritual master. If he remains dumb, then what bona fide spiritual master can do? Adau gurv-asrayam sad-dharma-prcchat, jijnasuh. He must be jijnasuh. He must be jijnasuh. We get so many letters daily. So many inquiries. The student must be very inquisitive. Otherwise how he shall make progress? If he remains dumb, then what the bona fide spiritual master can do?
‚If you go to a very nice school but if you do not study, if you do not inquire, then what is the use of going to the nice school? You must be also very alert to inquire, to understand, to make progress. Then it will be all right. If you do not utilize the benefit of having a bona fide spiritual master, then that is your fault. You must utilize the opportunity. We are publishing so many books, so many literatures, magazines, why? Just to enlighten more and more. But if you don’t take advantage of this, then how can you make progress? Change of spiritual master… requires when the spiritual master is not bonafide. Otherwise there is no necessity of changing
(Lecture London 9/23/69)
Generally the spiritual master comes from the group of such eternal associates of the Lord; but anyone who follows the principles of such ever liberated persons is as good as one in the above mentioned group.
A person who is liberated acharya and guru cannot commit any mistake, but there are persons who are less qualified or not liberated, but still can act as Guru and Acarya by strictly following the disciplic succession.
(Letter to Janardana 4/26/68)
This Krsna consciousness movement directly receives instructions from the Supreme personality of Godhead via persons who are strictly following His instructions. Although a follower may not be a liberated person, if he follows the supreme, liberated Personality of Godhead, his actions are naturally liberated from the contamination of the material nature.
Lord Caitanya therefore says: ‘By My order you may become a spiritual master.’ One can immediately become a spiritual master by having full faith in the transcendental words of the Supreme Personality of Godhead and by following His instructions.‛
(Srimad-Bhagavatam 4.18.5 ppt.)
DR.BENFORD: So everyone I might meet who accepts Krsna as the perfect teacher is the perfect teacher?
S.PRABHUPADA: Yes, because he is teaching only Krsna’s teachings, that’s all. It is the same as the example we gave before: They may not be personally perfect, but whatever they are speaking is perfect because it is taught by Krishna.”
(Consciousness: The Missing Link, pg. 14)
Narahari Sarakara Thakura in Krishna Bhajanamrita:
Even if in the performance of one’s devotional activities one has disobeyed the spiritual master, still one should not give him up, but should remain faithfully with him, because all authorities say that the shelter of one’s own spiritual master is best and perfect (even if another spiritual master is more powerful).
Kindly understand this example:
Just as one respects one’s father as a guru, his (the father’s) older and younger brothers are also similarly respected, but nonetheless, the father is worthy of the most respect. Not withstanding the above, if the father’s guru, even if he is family related, comes, one should double the respect, as he is the spiritual father of the father, or the guru of the guru. He is offered twice the puja or respect.
This behavior if recognized as appropriate by all authorities.
Just as if, during daily life, the brothers (older or younger) of the father criticize him, still one takes shelter of one’s father, similarly, one remains under the shelter of one’s own spiritual master, even if he is criticized by his older or younger godbrothers. Just as one depends upon one’s father for one’s livelihood, one must depend upon the strength and shelter of the spiritual master for advancing in devotional service.
If a father or spiritual master or husband are not possessed of outstanding qualities even then they are always worshipable.
Taking shelter of the above-mentioned persons one may even disagree with those senior to oneself.
In this world, what kind of person is there who can remain alive at the expense of his father’s or guru’s defamation or disgrace?
Everyone considers that if their spiritual master is very powerful then he himself is powerful but that if his spiritual master is less powerful, then he is, therefore, weaker, and according to the attitude of the spiritual master the disciple gains the same attributes. Those disciples who are intelligent can understand the desires of the spiritual master directly through their intelligence. Other disciples, who are less intelligent, understand by directly hearing instructions from the spiritual master. These activities are being practiced since time immemorial.
Learned Vaisnava authorities say that these instructions are the perfection of religiosity.
If the spiritual master commits a wrongful act breaking vaisnava regulative principles then in that case one should, in a solitary place, confront him for his rectification using logic and appropriate conclusions from sadhu, shastra, and guru references, but one is not to give him up.
One should not be hesitant or fearful because one is confronting or challenging a spiritual master.
“For it has been prescribed that one must appropriately discipline even a spiritual master who is :
• bewildered about what he should or shouldn’t do;
• who is inexperienced or ignorant;
• who has deviated from the Krsna conscious path;
• or is he is bewildered by false pride.”
This statement of the revealed scriptures is applicable at all times and under all circumstances.
The natural behavior of the vaisnava devotees is to take complete refuge of Lord Sri Krishna, the supreme Personality of Godhead, accepting Him as their principal and real shelter. The very life of the vaisnava devotees of the Lord is singling the glories or Lord Sri Krsna, describing and expanding the fame of Lord Sri Krsna, and discussing; the nectar of His transcendental pastimes.
The authorized course of action is to continue, as before, with one’s prescribed devotional service. One may take guidance through instructions from the vaisnavas as all vaisnavas are considered guru or “spiritual master”, or one may use one’s own intelligence, duly considering the relevant instructions from sadhu, shastra and guru. In all cases one should continue in one’s devotional service.
However, if the spiritual master:
• acts enviously towards ‘isvarebrantah’, that which is connected with the Supreme;
• is bewildered regarding the Supreme Personality of Godhead;
• is averse to expanding the fame of Lord Krsna;
• personally refuses to accept hearing or chanting about the glorious pastimes of Lord Sri Krsna;
• has become totally bewildered, listening to the false praise of ignorant persons and day by day is more materially contaminated and fallen
• then the spiritual master must be renounced.
Under those circumstances one should not doubt, “How can I give up my spiritual master?” With a strong desire for achieving spontaneous devotional service and attaining the lotus feet of Lord Krsna, the Supreme Personality of Godhead, a devotee accepts the shelter of a spiritual masters the via media to Lord Sri Krsna. However, after accepting the responsibility of serving the spiritual master, if that spiritual master takes on “asura” qualities or a demoniac mentality then it is one’s duty to reject such a demon “asura” guru and in his place accept a Krsna conscious spiritual master and worship him.
By taking shelter of the strength of the Krsna conscious spiritual master’s devotional service the ill effects or contamination of the demoniac previous spiritual master is counteracted and destroyed. These activities are recommended by all vaisnava authorities as the authorized conclusion of the shastra.
During the pastimes of Lord Sri Krsna Caitanya Mahaprabhu there have been many practical examples of the above.
This concludes the deliberation and final conclusions of sadhu, shastra and guru on the spiritual master and related matters.
– Manonatha Dasa (ACBSP)
18 feb 2020
- Please consider sending us a donation: click here
Post view 115 times from March 2020